Past journalers5 min read

The best way to read back your old journals

Rereading your own writing is harder than it sounds, and mostly for reasons nobody warns you about. A practical method, and what to do about the cringe.

Almost everyone who keeps a journal eventually tries to read it back. Most stop within twenty minutes.

This is not a discipline problem. Rereading your own writing has specific difficulties, and if you know what they are in advance you can work around them. If you do not, you conclude that your old journals are embarrassing and close the folder for another three years.

Why it goes wrong

The cringe is real and it is front-loaded. The first entries you open will almost certainly make you wince. You were more earnest than you remember, more repetitive, and more confident about things you turned out to be wrong about. This reaction is strongest in the first ten minutes and fades quickly, but most people quit inside that window and never discover it fades.

Context has evaporated. An entry written in a hurry assumes you know who "she" is and what happened on Tuesday. Two years later, you do not. A surprising share of any archive is simply unreadable for this reason.

Chronological order is the worst order. Days resemble the days either side of them. Read in sequence and the texture flattens into sameness, which is both boring and misleading — it was not like that to live.

You are looking for the wrong thing. People open old journals hoping for insight and find admin: what they ate, who they were annoyed by, what they meant to do. The insight is there, but it is distributed across many entries rather than sitting in any one of them.

The method that works

Read by thread, not by date

Pick one subject and follow it across the entire archive. One person. One decision. One piece of work. One recurring complaint.

Threads are finishable in a sitting, which matters more than it sounds — the reason chronological reading fails is that it has no end. A thread also puts the entries in meaningful relation to each other, so you see development rather than repetition.

The hard part is assembling the thread. Keyword search mostly does not work, because the words you used in 2019 are not the words you use now, and the most revealing entries are usually the ones where you never named the subject at all. This is the problem that reading across entries by meaning is built to solve, and if you have an archive from another app you can bring it in and let the threads assemble themselves.

Read a bounded period, not an era

If you want chronological reading, bound it hard. One year. The three months around a move. The weeks you were deciding something.

A bounded period has a shape — a beginning, a middle, and an end you already know — and that shape is what makes it readable. "My twenties" has no shape.

Read the gaps

The weeks you did not write are information.

Most people stop journalling when life is either very good or very bad, and a long silence in an archive almost always sits next to something. Notice the gaps and ask what was happening. Often you will remember immediately, and that memory is the entry you never wrote.

Keep what lands

Have somewhere to put the lines that stop you.

A sentence that reaches across four years and describes your present situation exactly is worth more than the fifty entries around it. If you have no way to keep it, you will lose it again and the rereading will have been entertainment rather than use. Highlighting as you go turns a session of rereading into something cumulative.

On the cringe, specifically

It is worth sitting with this rather than routing around it, because the embarrassment is itself the finding.

You cringe at an old entry because you can see something the person writing it could not. That gap is the change. It is the only direct evidence you will ever get that you are not the same person, and it is invisible from any other angle — your memory quietly updates your past self to agree with your present one, which is exactly why the written record is startling.

The psychologist James Pennebaker spent decades studying what happens when people write about their own experience, and one consistent finding across that body of expressive writing research is that the sense-making matters more than the venting — that what changes things is constructing a coherent account, not discharging the feeling. Rereading is the other half of that. It is where you find out what account you were constructing.

So: expect the first ten minutes to be unpleasant. Keep going. It does not stay unpleasant, and the discomfort is pointing at the thing you came for.

What to do with what you find

Reading back tends to produce three kinds of thing.

  • Things that resolved. You worried continuously about something for four months and it is now so far gone you had forgotten it happened. This is the most quietly useful category, because it is direct evidence about how your present worries will age.
  • Things that did not. A thread that runs for years, unchanged. Noticing one of these is uncomfortable and usually more important than anything else in the archive.
  • Things you were right about and ignored. Common, and galling. People frequently identify a problem correctly years before acting on it, in writing, and then do nothing.

None of these require a response. You do not have to turn rereading into a project. But if a thread runs for six years unchanged, you now know something you did not know this morning, and you knew it the whole time.

A session that works

Ninety minutes, once. Not a habit, not a system.

  1. Pick a thread, not a year.
  2. Read it front to back, in order, only that thread.
  3. Highlight anything that lands. Do not stop to think about it.
  4. At the end, read only your highlights.
  5. Write one entry about what you noticed.

That last step is the one people skip, and it is the one that compounds. The entry you write about reading your archive becomes, in time, one of the most useful entries in it — because it is the only kind written with hindsight already in hand.

If you are keeping a journal partly so that a future version of you can do exactly this, writing with that in mind is worth a few minutes' thought.

A journal that reads itself back

Ember reads across everything you write and surfaces what keeps returning. Bring an old archive with you, or start tonight.

Keep reading

  • Past journalers

    What to do with 10 years of journal entries

    A long archive is either an asset or a folder you never open, and the difference is what you do next. Four honest options for a decade of writing.

    5 min read